← All Essays
History 9 min read

Richard Garriott and the Open World

How Ultima built the template for virtual worlds before the internet existed to host them

From Akalabeth to Britannia

Richard Garriott sold his first game, Akalabeth, from a Ziploc bag at a ComputerLand store in 1979. The 28 copies sold that way eventually became a commercial product sold through California Pacific Computer Company; Garriott, then seventeen, received a $5 royalty per copy and earned approximately $150,000 from a game he had programmed in his bedroom. The success financed Ultima (1981), an open-world role-playing game that Garriott developed under the pseudonym Lord British — a nickname acquired at a Renaissance faire for his British accent — which he would maintain for the rest of his career.

Ultima (1981) and Ultima II (1982) were successful commercial products but relatively conventional for their era: dungeon-crawling RPGs with top-down world maps. Ultima III: Exodus (1983) introduced party-based combat that influenced virtually every JRPG that followed. Ultima IV: Quest of the Avatar (1985) was the radical departure: rather than defeating a villain, the player's goal was to embody eight virtues of ethical behaviour, becoming a moral exemplar for the people of Britannia. There was no final enemy to kill. Virtue itself was the game.

The Virtue System

Ultima IV's eight virtues — Honesty, Compassion, Valor, Justice, Sacrifice, Honor, Spirituality, and Humility — were tracked through the player's actions throughout the game world. Lying to NPCs reduced Honesty; fleeing from combat reduced Valor; donating to beggars increased Compassion. Every decision in the world had ethical implications that the game tracked silently, confronting players with the cumulative weight of their choices at the game's conclusion. This was morality not as a binary good/evil slider but as a multidimensional portrait of character.

The NPC world had gained unprecedented complexity through Ultima IV and V. Characters had names, occupations, schedules, and opinions about events in the game world. Asking an NPC about another character might provide genuine plot information; ignoring NPCs meant missing quests that could not be recovered. The sense that Britannia was a world that existed independently of the player — that NPCs went about their days whether the player interacted with them or not — predated the "living world" game design vocabulary by two decades.

Ultima VII: The Peak

Ultima VII: The Black Gate (1992) is frequently cited as the apex of the series and one of the most sophisticated RPGs ever created. Every object in the game world was individually modelled and interactive: bread could be baked from grain and flour; cows could be milked; the Fellowship cultists who served as antagonists had internal hierarchies, communication networks, and motivations that the player could investigate rather than being told. Killing NPCs was possible and had consequences — merchants killed for their gold left the economy of their town permanently damaged.

The Ultima Underworld games, developed by Looking Glass Studios rather than Origin under license, pushed this systemic complexity underground into fully three-dimensional dungeon environments. Ultima Underworld: The Stygian Abyss (1992) predated Doom by eighteen months with a fully navigable 3D environment that included physics, NPC factions, and environmental interaction — a game so technically and conceptually ahead of its time that its influence on first-person gaming is still being fully assessed.

Ultima Online and the Living World

Ultima Online (1997) was the logical extension of Garriott's world-building ambitions: a persistent online world where thousands of players simultaneously inhabited Britannia. The initial design included a predator-prey ecosystem where player hunters could reduce deer populations, reducing the food supply for wolves, creating ripple effects through the game ecology. Players immediately demonstrated that this idealistic design could not survive contact with the actual player population: deer were hunted to extinction within hours, the ecosystem collapsed, and the simulation had to be replaced with static population management.

The lesson — that player communities in virtual worlds behave in ways that idealistic design cannot anticipate — became the foundational knowledge base of MMO design. Ultima Online's experience shaped Everquest, World of Warcraft, and every persistent online world that followed, teaching designers that player behaviour in competitive environments defaults to optimization rather than roleplay, and that world ecology must be designed around those incentives rather than against them. Garriott's ambition had always been to create a virtual world; Ultima Online proved that creating one was far more complex than simulating one.